Skip to main content

Do calming treats for dogs work? A vet's opinion

Calming treats for dogs
(Image credit: Getty)

Does your dog get stressed out every time he hears a rumble of thunder? Does he bark his head off at the neighbor’s dogs across the street? You may have been tempted to purchase calming treats to help settle him down. But do calming treats for dogs really work? Although calming treats can help in some cases, they have very specific uses and they won’t work for all dogs. Calming treats work best for minor cases of stress and anxiety that just need a little something to take the edge off. Before you buy a new bag of calming treats, learn how to use them properly with these tips.

When to use calming dog treats

Calming treats are best suited for dogs that have mild anxiety. They can help take the edge off some minor nervousness, but they won’t magically cure your dog’s separation anxiety or leash reactivity. If your dog has relatively mild anxiety symptoms, such as lip-licking or occasional pacing, then calming treats may be enough to help take the edge off his anxiety and allow him to relax. However, severe anxiety symptoms such as restlessness, trembling, panting, or aggressive behavior are unlikely to resolve with calming treats. It’s also important to remember that calming treats alone won’t solve the underlying issue – as with any anxiety problem, a combination of both medication and training is needed to address the fear that triggers your dog’s anxiety behaviors. 

Types of calming treats for dogs

Some calming treats can be given on an as needed basis – such as just before a thunderstorm, fireworks, or a stressful car ride. Other types of calming treats need to be given daily over a longer period of time because the active ingredients need to build up in your dog’s body in order to work effectively. Calming supplements are also available, which are added to your dog’s food or given like a pill on a daily basis to help alleviate your dog’s anxiety. Your veterinarian can help you choose which type of calming treat or supplement is right for your dog based on your dog’s triggers and the severity of your dog’s anxiety.

The ingredients in calming treats vary widely depending on the product. Some calming products use herbal remedies to reduce stress and anxiety. Others rely on naturally occurring proteins such as casein and whey protein, which are derived from milk, and tryptophan, which is the amino acid that makes you feel sleepy after a big turkey dinner! Many manufacturers are also starting to incorporate CBD oil into their products, although more research is needed to determine its efficacy in treating canine anxiety.

Do calming treats for dogs work?

Calming treats for dogs can work well to alleviate mild stress and anxiety for some dogs. There are many different types of calming treats available on the market. What works well for one dog may not work as well for another, so you may experience some trial and error before finding the product that works best for your dog. Choose a product that is geared towards your dog’s situation: for example, if your dog is frightened of thunderstorms, a calming treat designed to be given on an as-needed basis, just before a storm begins, will likely be best. If your dog has anxiety daily, a product that is designed to be given on a daily basis will likely be a better fit. Before starting any new supplement, make sure to ask your veterinarian for recommendations – he or she may have a product in mind that will work best for your dog’s individual needs.

Calming treats for dogs

(Image credit: Getty)

What to do if calming treats don't work

If calming treats aren’t working well for your dog, it is likely because his anxiety is too severe for this very mild form of treatment. In these cases, a more in-depth treatment plan is necessary to address the behavior.

First, a visit to your veterinarian is in order. Your veterinarian will take a thorough history, including a detailed account of when the problem started, what triggers the anxious behavior, and what happens before, during, and after an anxious event. If possible, try to record your dog’s behavior at home so your veterinarian can get a detailed look at what is going on – this can be a huge help in identifying potential triggers for the behavior. Your veterinarian can then help you find ways to avoid or manage these triggers so that your dog will not be so stressed in the future.

Next, your veterinarian will perform a full physical examination on your dog and he or she may also recommend some additional diagnostic testing. This is an important step to identify any areas of pain or illness. Just like us, dogs can be more irritable, restless, stressed, anxious, or even aggressive if they’re not feeling well. Identifying and treating any underlying medical problems may help alleviate some of your dogs behavioral issues.

Finally, your veterinarian will discuss a behavior modification plan with you. Depending on the severity of your dog’s issues, this may include an at-home training plan, calming supplements, prescription medications, referral to a positive reinforcement-based dog trainer, or a consult with a board certified veterinary behaviorist. In some cases, you may be advised to pursue all of the above! It is very important to follow your veterinarian’s recommendations closely and follow up frequently so that your dog’s treatment plan can be adjusted as needed. Your dog’s success depends on the teamwork between you, your trainer, your veterinary team, and of course your pup!

Calming treats: Just one tool for canine anxiety

Many pet owners mistakenly believe that if calming treats don’t work, they’ve run out of options for treating their dog’s anxiety. This is not true!  Calming treats are just one tool for addressing canine anxiety and a very mild one at that. There are many other resources available to help your dog. Talk to your veterinarian to learn more about your options for prescription medications and positive reinforcement-based dog training, both of which can help address and manage your dog’s anxiety.

Elizabeth Racine, DVM

Since obtaining her doctorate in veterinary medicine, Dr. Racine has worked exclusively in small animal general practice. Her work has been featured in blog posts, articles, newsletters, journals, and even video scripts.