5 homemade puppy teething toys to soothe sore gums

Homemade puppy teething toys: Australian Shepherd puppy standing outside with soft toy
(Image credit: Getty Images)

Homemade puppy teething toys are a great way to help ease painful puppy mouths during their teething phase, all while saving money and enjoying the joy of crafting along the way. 

No matter how much you love your new furkid, owning a dog can be expensive, so DIY puppy toys are a great way to help keep costs down by using items you probably already have at home.

Puppies get their teeth at a much younger age than human babies do, so you’ll start to notice your ball of fur losing their baby teeth at around 3-4 months. The teething process can last anywhere from 8-12 weeks, so by six months of age, your pup’s 42 adult teeth should have come in - yes, you read that right, 42!

With all those teeth pushing through their gums, most puppies find the teething process to be highly uncomfortable and they’ll look for anything to chew as a way of relieving the pain they’re experiencing. Not only can specifically designed puppy toys help relieve discomfort, but they’ll also ensure your pup doesn’t turn to your furniture or shoes!

There's certainly a wide variety of good quality puppy teething toys on the market, but our ingenious ideas below will help you save money and keep your fur baby comfortable - now that’s what we call a win-win!

1. Puppy ice-pops

puppy ice-pop

(Image credit: Raising Rascal)

Making your own frozen dog treats may not be the first thing that springs to mind when you think of a teething toy, but these ice-pops won’t just help soothe inflamed gums, they’ll also keep your puppy amused for ages.


  • Fruit - bananas and strawberries make a great pair
  • Peanut butter
  • Yogurt
  • Ice cube trays


  1. Mash your chosen fruit. We love bananas and strawberries together, but you can use any dog-safe choice including blueberries, raspberries, and peaches.
  2. Add in a few teaspoons of peanut butter and yogurt.
  3. Pour the mixture into the ice cube trays and freeze overnight.

You can also make ice-pops using a low-sodium bone broth that you’ve made at home, so play around and see which one your pup prefers.

Recipe via Raising Rascal (opens in new tab)

2. Twisted tea towel

Instead of throwing out that old tea towel, give it a wash and repurpose it for your puppy to play with. Soak the towel in some sodium-free bone broth (chicken works nicely for this) and then wring it out and twist it tightly before popping it in the freezer overnight. When you get it out the next morning, your pup will have a tasty toy to chew on.

If you have a teacup dog breed, you’ll want something smaller than a tea towel as that will be too difficult for their little mouths to clamp down on, so opt for a flannel instead. Make sure you supervise your puppy when they’re playing with this toy and take it away once it’s defrosted so they don’t shred it and swallow any material. 

3. Frozen Kong toy

puppy kong

(Image credit: Kong)

If you’ve already got a few puppy toys lying around, chances are that one of them might be a Kong. The rubber design and hollow inner of the Kong make it an ideal option for when your fur baby is teething, but instead of giving them the toy on its own, why not make it more fun?

There are many Kong recipes you can make at home. Try smearing the inside with a little yogurt or cream cheese or for some long-lasting play, slather with sugar-free peanut butter, and then stick sliced banana, berries, or watermelon to the inner walls. Pop in the freezer and then once the fruit is solid, give it to your pup as an enriching and cooling treat.

4. Chamomile ice chips

Chamomile is a relaxing herb that has soothing properties that could help ease gum pain in your pup. Brew up a pot of chamomile tea and then pour it into ice cube trays and freeze. Once frozen, smash the cubes up so they’re not too big and fill an old glove. Tie a knot in the wrist to secure the chips inside. 

As your dog chews on the glove they’ll benefit from the coolness of the cubes and the chamomile will help relieve some of the discomfort we’re feeling. Although chamomile has been deemed safe for dogs in the right quantities, we recommend you have a chat with your vet first to make sure you’re getting the dosage right.

5. Sweet potato rope toy

Fiber and fun? We’re loving this one! All you need for this toy is some rope and a sweet potato and you’re good to go. Clean the sweet potato thoroughly and then cut it into 1-inch round pieces. Use a cookie cutter, a knife, or an apple corer to remove the middle of each round and then dehydrate by baking in the oven at 100 degrees celsius for around five hours. 

Once the sweet potatoes are cool, take a piece of rope about a foot long and tie a knot at one end. String the rings through and then tie a knot at the other end. Voila! You now have your very own healthy puppy teething toy.

Recipe via Elmo's Kitchen

Kathryn is a freelance writer who has spent the past two years dividing her writing time between her two great loves - pets and health and wellness. When she’s not busy crafting the perfect sentence for her features, buying guides and news pieces, she can be found hanging out with one very mischievous Cocker Spaniel, drinking copious amounts of Jasmine tea and attempting to set numerous world records for the longest ever FaceTime calls with her family back home in NZ.