Why is my flea treatment not working? A vet's guide to what to try next
Our vet answers the question "why is my flea treatment not working?" and reveals five common mistakes when treating fleas
The problem of a flea treatment not working is a pretty common scenario: you’ve bathed your pet, used a flea comb and applied the best flea treatment for dogs or the best flea treatment for cats, but still, the critters persist. Fleas are frustrating to get rid of, and can make you and your pet miserable, but what’s the best way to get rid of them?
This article will explore how to break the flea lifecycle once and for all, including addressing common reasons why your flea treatment isn't working and what to do once you've run out of options.
- Amazon: Save on flea treatments including up to 47% off Advantix (opens in new tab)
What is the flea lifecycle and why does it matter?
Fleas are one of the most common parasites that vets see in practice, in particular Ctenocephalides felis (opens in new tab) (the cat flea). This insect can infect cats, dogs and rabbits as well as biting humans too, causing itchiness but also transmitting disease (opens in new tab).
The flea life cycle is the term used to describe the stages that fleas go through to develop from eggs to mature adults. It’s important to understand this in order to tackle your parasite problem effectively, as discussed in scientific reviews such as this one (opens in new tab). Let’s explore this idea in more detail.
Adult fleas live mostly on your pet, although they may jump back off and spend some time in your house too. They lay tiny white eggs on your pet, which fall off into the carpet, but they may also lay eggs between the floorboards, in cracks in the tiles, and under the sofa — anywhere dark and hidden. These eggs hatch into little caterpillar-like larvae, which feed on dust, debris, and poo from the adults.
Once they’ve grown large enough, the larvae pupate, spinning a camouflaged cocoon from carpet fibres and dust. In the pupa, they transform from this caterpillar-like legless larva into an adult flea with long legs for jumping and an appetite for animal blood. They may then hatch or — if they sense conditions aren’t right — they could wait in the cocoon, protected, for several months if necessary. None of the flea products on the market can kill flea pupae.
There are three important things to note here:
- Fleas go through four life stages
- Only a very small proportion of the infestation is the adult fleas on your pet
- None of the flea-killing products can get through the cocoon and kill the pupa
Amazon Prime Day deal: K9 Advantix II Flea and Tick Prevention for Large Dogs
RRP: $59.98 | Now: $31.52 | Save: $28.46 (47%) (opens in new tab)
Keep your dog protected from pesky parasites for a quarter of the year with this great deal on a four pack of topical treatments from Advantix. Suitable for pups weighing 21 - 55 lbs, it's easy to apply and starts working within 12 hours.
What does this mean for treating fleas on my pet?
Understanding the flea life cycle is key to treating this parasite effectively. Firstly, it’s important to understand that most flea products contain an adulticide – a chemical to kill the adults. Some – but not all – will also contain ingredients that will kill the eggs/larvae. This is usually an insect growth regulator, which prevents the immature fleas from developing and moving through the life cycle.
If you only kill the adults, you will need to treat the infestation long enough for all the eggs to hatch into larvae, all the larvae to pupate, and all the pupae to hatch into mature fleas– that could take 5-6 months! So, finding a product that targets adults as well as the immature stages of the flea is crucial.
Secondly, it’s important to remember that the cocoon stage is immune to all known insecticides… and it can survive in that stage for 12 weeks or more if conditions aren’t right for hatching.
Even if you kill the adults, the eggs, and the larvae, nothing will kill the pupae in their cocoons. So you need to treat your pet for long enough for all the existing pupae in your house to hatch into adults so the adulticide can kill them – that can still take at least 3 months!
If you accidentally break your pet’s treatment program at any point during this time, the pupae can hatch, feed, and start laying eggs again. This will undo all your good work and start your infestation again, setting your time-to-clear clock back to zero.
Common mistakes when using flea treatment
1. Using flea shampoo
One really common scenario is a frustrated pet parent who uses flea shampoo, then applies, for example, a topical flea treatment for cats, to kill the fleas. Many of the spot-on flea products use the natural oils of the coat to spread the flea treatment over your pet.
So, if you’ve just washed your pet and stripped the natural oils, they’ll be less effective. Check the packaging for specific recommendations, but most say you cannot apply within 48 hours of a bath, and you shouldn’t bathe your dog for at least 48 hours after application, either.
Even after the medication has dried, repeated washing during treatment with spot-ons will reduce effectiveness. There is no need to use a flea shampoo, just stick to effective veterinary recommended flea products.
2. Not treating all your pets
There’s no point in treating your dogs if the adult fleas can feed on your rabbit, or on the neighbour’s cat that sleeps on your sofa sometimes!
The minute you forget a day of your dog’s treatment or use a sub-standard product, they’ll catch fleas again. Make sure you treat all the animals in the house so the adult fleas have nowhere safe to go. If you have a visiting cat, please check with their owner before applying flea treatment, to avoid accidental double-dosing.
If you aren’t sure who the owner is, a cat-safe paper collar is a good way to send a message home asking someone to call you.
3. Not waiting long enough
We’ve hit on this a couple of times already, but just to reiterate – in my experience, the single most common reason for flea treatment failure is not understanding just how long it takes to get rid of an infestation. Pet parents often have unrealistic expectations, especially if they buy a product from the vets – but the truth is, the pupae can wait 12 weeks to hatch, which means you need to treat for 12 weeks, without a gap, to beat them. To avoid this situation from occurring in the first place, use preventive flea products regularly to give your pet (and home!) protection against infestations.
4. Using bad, out-of-date, or fake products
Sometimes things are too good to be true. If the flea treatment seems a lot cheaper than you’re used to, ask yourself why. Could the product be out of date? Did it come from a reputable source? Does it actually claim to kill fleas, or does it just repel them? If you’ve used a sub-standard product, it stands to reason the result might not be what you want. There are also fakes circulating, so you might have done your best but still been caught out.
Whilst an adulticide treatment appears to be cheaper than one that treats more life stages, remember that you’ll need to treat for twice as long to get rid of a flea infestation! PetsRadar has buying guides to all types of effective flea treatment including the best flea collar for dogs and the best flea collar for cats, along with the best flea medication for dogs.
5. Not treating the house
If your product only contains an adulticide, you still need to kill the eggs and larvae in the house. One way of doing this is with a house spray or flea bomb. Many of these products last for several months in the environment, so only need to be applied a couple of times a year. It’s easy to forget this step, but using flea spray takes the time to treat the infestation from 6 months to 3 months!
Can I reapply flea treatment if it doesn’t work?
If you’ve applied flea treatment but can still see live fleas on your pet, you should resist the urge to re-apply the flea treatment. Doubling up on dosing can be dangerous for your pet, and unnecessary, if you are using already using an effective flea product. If you remember the flea life cycle, you will still be having pupae hatching in the environment with the adult fleas hopping onto your pet for a few months.
The good news is that after encountering your pet and their flea product these fleas should shortly die without reproducing. Sometimes the fleas may be hyperexcitable before they keel over and die, which could be what you are seeing. However, if you are still seeing high numbers of fleas or if you have concerns about the quality of your flea product then call your veterinarian for advice.
There will likely be a waiting period (of a few days or weeks) before you can apply another flea treatment, depending on what you’ve already used. However, in some cases, new and more effective flea treatment can be safely prescribed, but your vet will advise further.
Amazon Prime Day deal: Advantage II Flea Prevention and Treatment for Small Cats
RRP: $71.98 | Now: $39.89 | Save: $32.09 (45%) (opens in new tab)
This handy six pack of topical treatments will keep your small fur friend flea-free for six months. Suitable for cats weighing between 5 and 9 lbs, it's easy to apply, fragrance free and waterproof after 24 hours.
Why is my dog or cat still scratching after flea treatment?
Of course, there are other reasons why your pet might be needing to itch. If you’ve treated them with a good product for at least 12 weeks without a gap, and have seen no sign of fleas, it’s possible fleas weren’t the main problem. There are other common causes of itchiness in pets, including allergies, skin infections, other parasites, and even anxiety. If your pet is still scratching after flea treatment, call your vet for help.
What to do if your flea treatment still isn't working
It’s time to go and see your vet. Don’t be embarrassed – your local veterinarian deals with fleas all the time and it is no reflection on your home or ability to care for your pet.
Your vet will be able to work out what’s gone wrong and help you to get rid of the fleas. If your pet has seen the vet within the last 6-12 months, they may even not need to be seen and may instead prescribe some treatment over the phone and give you up-to-date advice. If your pet does need to be seen, a ‘flea check’ is often free!
So now you know the biggest mistakes made when people think their flea treatment is not working, hopefully you can avoid making these mistakes yourself. You’ll also know the importance of treating your pet for several months without a break in order to ensure the infestation has gone.
Get the best advice, tips and top tech for your beloved Pets
After graduating as a veterinarian from the University of Nottingham, Dr Joanna Woodnutt went on to practice companion animal medicine in the Midlands. She quickly developed a love of consulting and helping clients with medical problems such as dermatology, behaviour and nutrition - anything that involved helping clients understand their pets better. Jo started writing about pet health in 2017, realising that it meant she could help even more pet parents. Since then, she has written for countless online and print publications and is a regular contributor for Edition Dog Magazine. Jo now lives in the Channel Islands with her husband Ian and terrier Pixie, and they are expecting their first child very soon.